Excel Icon Sets conditional formatting: inbuilt and custom

The article provides detailed guidance on how to use conditional formatting Icon Sets in Excel. It will teach you how to create a custom icon set that overcomes many limitations of the inbuilt options and apply icons based on another cell value.

A while ago, we started to explorer various features and capabilities of Conditional Formatting in Excel. If you haven't got a chance to read that introductory article, you may want to do this now. If you already know the basics, let's move on and see what options you have with regard to Excel's icon sets and how you can leverage them in your projects.

Excel icon sets

Icon Sets in Excel are ready-to-use formatting options that add various icons to cells, such as arrows, shapes, check marks, flags, rating starts, etc. to visually show how cell values in a range are compared to each other.

Normally, an icon set contains from three to five icons, consequently the cell values in a formatted range are divided into three to five groups from high to low. For instance, a 3-icon set uses one icon for values greater than or equal to 67%, another icon for values between 67% and 33%, and yet another icon for values lower than 33%. However, you are free to change this default behavior and define your own criteria. Excel Icon Sets: inbuilt and custom

How to use icon sets in Excel

To apply an icon set to your data, this is what you need to do:

  1. Select the range of cells you want to format.
  2. On the Home tab, in the Styles group, click Conditional Formatting.
  3. Point to Icon Sets, and then click the icon type you want.

That's it! The icons will appear inside the selected cells straight away. Using an icon set in Excel

How to customize Excel icon sets

If you are not happy with the way Excel has interpreted and highlighted your data, you can easily customize the applied icon set. To make edits, follow these steps:

  1. Select any cell conditionally formatted with the icon set.
  2. On the Home tab, click Conditional Formatting > Manage Rules.
  3. Select the rule of interest and click Edit Rule. Customize an Excel icon sets.
  4. In the Edit Formatting Rule dialog box, you can choose other icons and assign them to different values. To select another icon, click on the drop-down button and you will see a list of all icons available for conditional formatting. Choose another icon.
  5. When done editing, click OK twice to save the changes and return to Excel.

For our example, we've chosen the red cross to highlight values greater than or equal to 50% and the green tick mark to highlight values less than 20%. For in-between values, the yellow exclamation mark will be used. A customized icon set

Tips:

  • To reverse icon setting, click the Reverse Icon Order button.
  • To hide cell values and show only icons, select the Show Icon Only check box.
  • To define the criteria based on another cell value, enter the cell's address in the Value box.
  • You can use icon sets together with other conditional formats, e.g. to change the background color of the cells containing icons.

How to create a custom icon set in Excel

In Microsoft Excel, there are 4 different kinds of icon sets: directional, shapes, indicators and ratings. When creating your own rule, you can use any icon from any set and assign any value to it.

To create your own custom icon set, follow these steps:

  1. Select the range of cells where you want to apply the icons.
  2. Click Conditional Formatting > Icon Sets > More Rules.
  3. In the New Formatting Rule dialog box, select the desired icons. From the Type dropdown box, select Percentage, Number of Formula, and type the corresponding values in the Value boxes.
  4. Finally, click OK.

For this example, we've created a custom three-flags icon set, where:

  • Green flag marks household spendings greater than or equal to $100.
  • Yellow flag is assigned to numbers less than $100 and greater than or equal to $30.
  • Green flag is used for values less than $30.
A custom three-flags icon set

How to set conditions based on another cell value

Instead of "hardcoding" the criteria in a rule, you can input each condition in a separate cell, and then refer to those cells. The key benefit of this approach is that you can easily modify the conditions by changing the values in the referenced cells without editing the rule.

For example, we've entered the two main conditions in cells G2 and G3 and configured the rule in this way:

  • For Type, pick Formula.
  • For the Value box, enter the cell address preceded with the equality sign. To get it done automatically by Excel, just place the cursor in the box and click the cell on the sheet. Define the icon set conditions based on another cell.

Excel conditional formatting icon sets formula

To have the conditions calculated automatically by Excel, you can express them using a formula.

To apply conditional formatting with formula-driven icons, start creating a custom icon set as described above. In the New Formatting Rule dialog box, from the Type dropdown box, select Formula, and insert your formula in the Value box.

For this example, the following formulas are used:

  • Green flag is assigned to numbers greater than or equal to an average + 10:

    =AVERAGE($B$2:$B$13)+10

  • Yellow flag is assigned to numbers less than an average + 10 and greater than or equal to an average - 20.

    =AVERAGE($B$2:$B$13)-20

  • Green flag is used for values lower than an average - 20.
Create a conditional formatting icon set using a formula.

Note. It's not possible to use relative references in icon set formulas.

Excel conditional format icon set to compare 2 columns

When comparing two columns, conditional formatting icon sets, such as colored arrows, can give you an excellent visual representation of the comparison. This can be done by using an icon set in combination with a formula that calculates the difference between the values in two columns - the percent change formula works nicely for this purpose.

Suppose you have the June and July spendings in columns B and C, respectively. To calculate how much the amount has changed between the two months, the formula in D2 copied down is:

=C2/B2 - 1 The percent change formula to compare the values in the two columns

Now, we want to display:

  • An up arrow if the percent change is a positive number (value in column C is greater than in column B).
  • A down arrow if the difference is a negative number (value in column C is less than in column B).
  • A horizontal arrow if the percent change is zero (columns B and C are equal).

To accomplish this, you create a custom icon set rule with these settings:

  • A green up arrow when Value is > 0.
  • A yellow right arrow when Value is <=0 and >=0, which limits the choice to zeros.
  • A red down arrow when Value is < 0.
  • For all the icons, Type is set to Number.

At this point, the result will look something like this: Excel icon set to compare 2 columns

To show only the icons without percentages, tick the Show Icon Only checkbox. Compare two columns using only the icons.

How to apply Excel icon sets based on another cell

A common opinion is that Excel conditional formatting icon sets can only be used to format cells based on their own values. Technically, that is true. However, you can emulate the conditional format icon set based on a value in another cell.

Suppose you have payment dates in column D. Your goal is to place a green flag in column A when a certain bill is paid, i.e. there is a date in the corresponding cell in column D. If a cell in column D is blank, a red flag should be inserted.

To accomplish the task, these are the steps to perform:

  1. Start with adding the below formula to A2, and then copy it down the column:

    =IF($D2<>"", 3, 1)

    The formula says to return 3 if D2 is not empty, otherwise 1. Formula to identify blank and non-blank cells

  2. Select the data cells in column A without the column header (A2:A13) and create a custom icon set rule.
  3. Configure the following settings:
    • Green flag when the number is >=3.
    • Yellow flag when the number is >2. As you remember, we do not really want a yellow flag anywhere, so we set a condition that will never be satisfied, i.e. a value less than 3 and greater than 2.
    • In the Type dropdown box, pick Number for both icons.
    • Select the Icon Set Only checkbox to hide the numbers and only show the icons.

The result is exactly as we were looking for: the green flag if a cell in column D contains anything in it and the red flag if the cell is empty. Configure an Excel icon sets based on another cell.

Excel conditional formatting icon sets based on text

By default, Excel icon sets are designed for formatting numbers, not text. But with just a little creativity, you can assign different icons to specific text values, so you can see at a glance what text is in this or that cell.

Suppose you've added the Note column to your household spendings table and want to apply certain icons based on the text labels in that column. The task requires some preparatory work such as:

  • Make a summary table (F2:G4) numbering each note. The idea is to use a positive, negative, and zero number here.
  • Add one more column to the original table named Icon (it's where the icons are going to be placed).
  • Populated the new column with a VLOOKUP formula that looks up the notes and returns matching numbers from the summary table:

    =VLOOKUP(C2, $F$2:$G$4, 2, FALSE)

    Summary table and VLOOKUP formula

Now, it's time to add icons to our text notes:

  1. Select the range D2:D13 and click Conditional Formatting> Icon Sets > More Rules.
  2. Choose the icon style you want and configure the rule as in the image below: An icon set rule for text values
  3. The next step is to replace the numbers with text notes. This can be done by applying a custom number format. So, select the range D2:D13 again and press the CTRL + 1 shortcut.
  4. In the Format Cells dialog box, on the Number tab, select the Custom category, enter the following format in the Type box, and click OK:

    "Good";Exorbitant";"Acceptable"

    Where "Good" is the display value for positive numbers, "Exorbitant" for negative numbers, and "Acceptable" for 0. Please be sure to correctly replace those values with your text.

    This is very close to the desired result, isn't it? Apply a custom format for positive numbers, negative numbers, and zeros.

  5. To get rid of the Note column, which has become redundant, copy the contents of the Icon column, and then use the Paste Special feature to paste as values in the same place. However, please keep in mind that this will make your icons static, so they won't respond to changes in the original data. If you are working with an updatable dataset, skip this step.
  6. Now, you can safely hide or delete (if you replaced the formulas with calculated values) the Note column without affecting the text labels and symbols in the Icon column. Done! Conditional formatting icon sets for text values

Note. In this example, we've used a 3-icon set. Applying 5-icon sets based on text is also possible but requires more manipulations.

How to show only some items of the icon set

Excel's inbuilt 3-icon and 5-icon sets look nice, but sometimes you may find them a bit inundated with graphics. The solution is to keep only those icons that draw attention to the most important items, say, best performing or worst performing.

For example, when highlighting the spendings with different icons, you may want to show only those that mark the amounts higher than average. Let's see how you can do this:

  1. Create a new conditional formatting rule by clicking Conditional formatting > New Rule > Format only cells that contain. Choose to format cells with values less than average, which is returned by the below formula. Click OK without setting any format.

    =AVERAGE($B$2:$B$13) Create a conditional formatting rule with no format set for values less than average.

  2. Click Conditional Formatting > Manage Rules…, move up the Less than average rule, and put a tick into the Stop if True check box next to it.

As a result, the icons are only shown for the amounts that are greater than average in the applied range: The icons are only shown for the amounts greater than average.

How to add custom icon set to Excel

Excel's built-in sets have a limited collection of icons and, unfortunately, there is no way to add custom icons to the collection. Luckily, there is a workaround that allows you to mimic conditional formatting with custom icons.

Method 1. Add custom icons using Symbol menu

To emulate Excel conditional formatting with a custom icon set, these are the steps to follow:

  1. Create a reference table outlining your conditions as shown in the screenshot below.
  2. In the reference table, insert the desired icons. For this, clicking the Insert tab > Symbols group > Symbol button. In the Symbol dialog box, select the Windings font, pick the symbol you want, and click Insert.
  3. Next to each icon, type its character code, which is displayed near the bottom of the Symbol dialog box. Insert custom icons from the Symbols menu.
  4. For the column where the icons should appear, set the Wingdings font, and then enter the nested IF formula like this one:

    =IF(B2>=90, CHAR(76), IF(B2>=30, CHAR(75), CHAR(74)))

    With cell references, it takes this shape:

    =IF(B2>=$H$2, CHAR($F$2), IF(B2>=$H$3, CHAR($F$3), CHAR($F$4)))

    Copy the formula down the column, and you will get this result: A custom icon set based on a formula

Black and white icons appear rather dull, but you can give them a better look by coloring the cells. For this, you can apply the inbuilt rule (Conditional Formatting > Highlight Cells Rules > Equal To) based on the CHAR formula such as:

=CHAR(76)

Now, our custom icon formatting looks nicer, right? Custom icons in colored cells

Method 2. Add custom icons using virtual keyboard

Adding custom icons with the help of the virtual keyboard is even easier. The steps are:

  1. Start by opening the virtual keyboard on the task bar. If the keyboard icon is not there, right-click on the bar, and then click Show Touch Keyboard Button.
  2. In your summary table, select the cell where you want to insert the icon, and then click on the icon you like.

    Alternatively, you can open the emoji keyboard by pressing the Win + . shortcut (the Windows logo key and the period key together) and select the icons there. Insert custom icons from the emoji keyboard.

  3. In the Custom Icon column, enter this formula:

    =IF(B2>=$G$2, $E$2, IF(B2>=$G$3, $E$3, $E$4))

    In this case, you need neither the character codes nor fiddling with the font type.

When added to Excel desktop, the icons are black and white: Formula to conditionally format data with custom icons

In Excel Online, colored icons look a lot more beautiful: Conditional format with colored custom icons

This is how to use icon sets in Excel. Upon a closer look, they are capable of a lot more than just a few preset formats, right? If you are curious to learn other conditional formatting types, the tutorials linked below may come in handy.

Practice workbook for download

Conditional formatting icon sets in Excel - examples (.xlsx file)

Table of contents

162 comments

  1. Not seeing (within the above) an example of how to set up rules for a single column. Currently, I have a range that I've converted into an Excel TABLE and it's called: "Tabletotexc". It's range is F1 through S32. The only 2 columns of concern are COL F and COL G...... COL F Header in F1 "Period": then these dates start in F2 going down... FY23-06, FY23-07, FY23-08, FY23-09, FY23-10, FY23-11, FY23-12, FY24,01, FY24-02...... COL G Header in G1: "Tot Sales": then random amounts all the way down... I have selected G2:G32 and turned on Conditional Format..... The Green, Yellow, Red arrows are currently showing up WITHIN THE SAME CELL as each amount, however, they're not accurately POINTING IN CORRECT DIRECTION to show whether that SALES figure is UP from the previous month or if SALES has gone down. How do I fix the settings to accurately look at the cell above it and compare to it and keep the arrow within the same cell as the dollar amt in COL G. So for example, G2 is the first amount: $25,000, G3 is the 2nd month's amount $30,000 so the cell G3 would have a GREEN UP ARROW, G4 would be the 3rd month in line $5,000. (should have a RED DOWN ARROW) next to that $5k figure. If G4 is again $5,000 then it would have the YELLOW SIDEWAYS ARROW... and continue down to end of range. My settings are: Format Style "Icon Sets", Icon Style: (shows the 3 arrows), down below on right, need help to know whether to choose TYPE: Number, Formula, Percent, etc. and what to put in the VALUE fields. Thanks greatly! If this is something that can be accomplished with VBA, even better, would love to be able to copy/paste test code to see if that works.

      • Thank you for your response @alexander trifuntov (Ablebits Team) but when I attempt that, it does not work and gives "You cannot use relative references in Conditional Formatting criteria for color scales, data bars, and icon sets. Here's what I did to verify I followed your instructions correctly: Col G holds the data that I'd like the icons within. G1 is the header so couldn't use that as you'd mentioned. EXACT STEPS: I highlighted G2:G32, clicked Conditional Formatting, chose "Format all cells based on their values" at top within the SELECT A RULE TYPE section, then within FORMAT STYLE, chose icon sets, within the bottom right area called ***TYPE: I chose "Formula"*** as you instructed. Chose "FORMULA" (on both lines where a value can be entered), entered the formula =G3>G2 in the top one and =G3 Format Style > Icon Sets then within the "TYPE" field there, choose Formula and make it work.. everything I've tried has not worked.. =-(

  2. How do you find the symbol code now? It's no longer available when you go to the symbols menu in the new update, i've also tried replacing "CHAR(#)" with "UNICODE(U+####A)" but it throws an error. Trying to input a basic white smiley with >0 and basic white frowny with =0%. The formatting for interpretation is correct but I can't figure out the smileys :(.

    =IF([@Score]>0, UNICODE(U+263A), IF([@Score]=0, UNICODE(U+264A)))

    • Hi! I am using Excel365 and I am experiencing the same issue as described in the article. Unfortunately I am unable to reproduce your problem.

  3. How can I format an Icon to reset to a specific value based on a date change? For example on a weekly schedule I want all the green checks to reset to red x's once the date moves to the following week? I don't see a way to add the date condition to the icon set. Thanks

  4. Hi, how to make conditional format contain tick symbol (green colour) and cross mark symbol (red color) without value? I tried to drag down the format along the same column but the only one colour can appear because it follows only the first checkbox's colour. Even the cross mark symbol turn into green colour.

  5. Completely unacceptable. I want arrows pointing up or down based on the value in another cell. I should not have to have a dedicated cell purely for the icon, I should be able to show both. Absolutely insane.

  6. Hello, I am trying to use Icon sets to show when a certificate has expired based on the date of completion. For example,

    Someone completed their First Aid Certificate on the 14/07/2023. The certificate lasts 3 years I want to use Icon sets to show when the certificate

    in date (green) where there is 365 days or more left on the certificate

    expiring (Yellow) when there is only 90 days left

    Expired (Red) when o days left.

    Is this possible?

  7. Is there an option to move the position of arrow indicators from Left to Right side of the value

  8. Anybody knows why when i try to set up cell fill gradient based on its values. There is three points in Conditional formatting rules, Lowest value, midpoint and Highest value, However none of them works as it should, Colour doesnt change with its values. I dont understand it.

  9. "A common opinion is that Excel conditional formatting icon sets can only be used to format cells based on their own values. But this is a delusion."

    It's not a delusion though is it? All of your examples demonstrate adding an additional column and then applying an icon set to cells in that column based on the derived value captured within the cells.

    So as far as I can see the common opinion is the correct opinion.

    • Agreed, I was trying to use an arrow or bullet in front of info in column D based on formula from column A. Since my data imports with the same cells all I would need to do is format paint the sheet. With this solution I would need to continually add columns.

  10. I have created an excel sheet which has a list of projects with the names of the PM which highlights the submission dates of their status reports. I want to use the icon sets to highlight and show the dates that reflect early submission, late submissions and on time submissions.

    The due dates are listed in the table in rows above each month. The due date is 5 May 2021 for the April Report. If persons submit on the 4 of May, the green icon should come up, if the report is submitted on time that is 5 May 2021, the yellow icon is used, if the report is late that is 6 May the red icon should appear.

    I am having issues making the argument and getting the icon i want.

    Help!

    • Hi!
      Have you tried the ways described in this blog post? Use Icon Set for your data. Then use Manage Rules - Edit Rule and set the conditions you need for each icon.

    • Sorry for late reply.
      In excel each date can be converted in numbers, hence subtract the submission date with that that of due date, all the negative number reflects before submission, zero reflect on date submission, and positive numbers reflects late submission. Use inverse order as discussed in the blog (Green for negative, yellow for zero and red positive numbers)

  11. I need to set appointments by time slot. They are set 15 minutes apart. The times are across the top. The services are 1 hour or 2 hour slots with a 15 minute break between. They need to expand a bar across the times (cells in a row) the appointment will take. I can set up colors and text with conditional formatting but cannot seem to get it to move across more than one cell/column in a row for the amount of time each appointment will take. Is there a way to do it?

  12. I would like to have icons appear on cells that is a value percentage based on a particular cell

    basically
    Salary $1500
    Budget (66%) = $990
    Spending $1300

    Now to keep track of my budget budget, regardless of what my salary changes to be, I'd like to have indicators/icons when my spending is at 30% (green flag), 50% (yellow flag) and 60% (red flag) of my salary without having to individually set each cell every month when the salary changes, as it varies every month. Is this possible?

    In the amounts given above, the indicator will be a redflag that shows i am beyond my budget

  13. Hi Experts,
    What values to type in dialogue box for conditioning formating arrow icon sets like positive percentage with green colour arrow, zero percentage with yellow arrow and negative percentage with red arrow?

  14. hi, first of, thank you for the tutor!

    how do i do the icon condition if i want to set cell againts cell againts cell?
    eg: say is the gross profit for the month
    c1: 20,000 (jan20)
    e1: 15,000 (dec19)
    g1: 22,000 (nov19)

    what i would like to create is there is the arrow showing up or down againts the previous month. not againts a "base number"

Post a comment



Thank you for your comment!
When posting a question, please be very clear and concise. This will help us provide a quick and relevant solution to
your query. We cannot guarantee that we will answer every question, but we'll do our best :)